
As Roblox pushes child-safety lawsuits into private arbitration, courts are divided over whether a child’s “I agree” binds the child or the parent.
If you’re the parent of a child or pre-teen, Roblox might be your best friend—or your biggest nemesis. Past lawsuits have accused the video game Roblox of being addictive for kids, and causing financial, physical, and mental harm.
But the legal question involving the video game giant today is different from what we’ve seen before.
In a 2025 lawsuit against Roblox, the question is whether a child clicking “I agree” to a waiver in an app can mean that the parents forfeit their right to hold the app liable for harm.
This is one of the central questions in the growing litigation against Roblox. The answer could decide whether families who claim Roblox harmed their children have a public trial or a private, closed-door arbitration.
How much do waivers matter, anyway?
First, let’s talk about liability waivers, generally. Typically, a court will treat a pre-injury liability waiver (sometimes called an “exculpatory agreement” or “express assumption of risk agreement”) as a valid contract that can shield a business from claims for ordinary negligence, but only if the language is clear, unambiguous and conspicuous, specifically covers the type of harm that occurred, and was signed voluntarily by someone with legal capacity.
However, even if the waiver is well-drafted, it likely won’t protect against gross negligence, recklessness, or intentional misconduct. Courts can void waivers that violate public policy. States are split on whether a parent may waive a minor child’s future injury claims; some will enforce this type of waiver, but many don’t. However, the doctrine typically doesn’t cover risks the defendant created or increased through its own carelessness.
Seitz v. Roblox Corporation, 2:25-cv-00166, (E.D. Ky.)
In October 2025, Jaimee Seitz filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Roblox, alleging that the company was responsible for her daughter’s suicide at age 13. Seitz’s daughter, Audree Heine, joined Roblox when she was eight years old. Although her mother set parental controls on the account, Audree was exposed to harmful and violent influences through the video game, ultimately leading her to take her own life.
Discord was named as a co-defendant in the lawsuit, based on the allegation that Audree’s exposure began on Roblox and then continued her interactions on Discord, where she faced further manipulation and social pressure. The complaint names Discord as the platform where users shared advice on building school-shooting simulators and designing Roblox avatars that take the appearance of notorious school shooters. The complaint also alleges that both platforms lack adequate age verification for underage users. TikTok was added as a defendant after the original lawsuit against Roblox and Discord.
How did Roblox respond to the lawsuit?
Roblox filed a motion to the Eastern District of Kentucky to compel arbitration.
Its argument was that Audree and her family waived her right to a jury trial 28 times—once when she created her account, six times when she accepted updates to the Roblox Terms of Service, twice through Roblox gift card redemptions, and 19 times by purchasing Robux.
Discord also argued that Audree was bound to arbitration because she entered an adult birthdate when she registered for the platform at eight years old. Seitz responded that her daughter was a child, and did not understand arbitration or contracts.
This case is not unique. Roblox is working to move more than 150 federal cases involving child exploitation and harm into private arbitration. Its arbitration strategy is a systematic legal approach, not a case-specific defense. A group of parents argued in federal court in October 2026 that the mass arbitration framework that Roblox is aiming for could unfairly bind parents to decisions they’re unable to contest.
Read more:
What’s a “clickwrap” agreement?
You’ve agreed to these. We all have. You probably agreed to one today.
A clickwrap agreement is the contract formed when you check a box or select “I agree” to a website’s terms. Courts will typically enforce these agreements when they’re against adults who had reasonable notice of the terms. But most gaming and social media apps’ terms of service include a buried arbitration clause, which sends a dispute to a private arbitrator, instead of a judge and jury. This often means limited discovery, no public record, and narrow grounds for appeal.

But it’s different when an adult clicks on “I agree” and when a child does so. In most states, the long-standing law is that a minor can generally disaffirm (cancel) a contract they entered into. That’s why companies sometimes argue that a parent agreed to the terms, or that the family is bound because the child used the account for many years and used it for purchases.
The infancy doctrine
The infancy doctrine is recognized in almost every state. A contract signed by a minor is generally voidable, rather than void. In other words, the child may disaffirm it before they turn 18, or within a reasonable time afterward, and they can walk away from its terms. For a parent, the practical step is a clear, written disaffirmance. In Audree Heine’s case, her mother expressly disaffirmed any alleged contract that contained an arbitration agreement on behalf of her daughter’s estate.
But software companies have counterarguments, and sometimes the courts accept them.
The child continued to use the service
Some courts have held that a minor may not disaffirm the terms while they continue to use the platform. (C.M.D. v. Facebook, 2015)
The child lied about their age
In some states, a minor who claimed to be an adult could be blocked from disaffirming. This is the theory behind the Discord argument that Audree was bound to the agreement, partly because she entered an adult birthdate.
An arbitrator should decide
Many terms of service have a “delegation clause,” which means any question about the contract’s validity would go to an arbitrator. That means a judge would never reach the question of a minor’s capacity to commit to a contract. In the California video game addiction litigation, Epic Games pointed to half a dozen recent federal cases that sent similar claims to arbitration, despite arguments based on minors’ lack of capacity, disaffirmance and unconscionability.
Is a parent bound by a child’s contract?
A child’s click is not the parent’s signature.
But a parent can become bound in their own right:
- If they agreed. This includes creating the account, entering a credit card, setting up parental controls, or accepting updated terms. Many platforms’ terms state that the parent agrees on the child’s behalf and on their own.
- By letting the child use the parent’s account or payment method. A court may treat the child as acting with the parent’s authority.
This is why the case will hinge entirely on the evidence. In the Los Angeles case, Roblox lost because an account linked to the mother’s email did not prove that she, as an adult, had agreed to the terms. In a separate case, claims against Roblox and Microsoft were sent to arbitration because the evidence differed on whether the parents bound the minor.
State law determines whether the parent’s own claims are bound to arbitration. The parent may file a lawsuit for their own losses (medical bills, or wrongful death if a child dies), and these claims belong to the parent, rather than the child. Occasionally, a court will permit a parent to bring these claims to court even if the child’s claims will go to arbitration. Other courts will hold the parents to the arbitration clause, either because the parent agreed or because the claim is treated as a derivative of the child’s claim.
If you’re a parent of a child who uses apps and games, keep a record of who clicked what and when. If your child was harmed, don’t concede that a checkbox settles the question before a lawyer has reviewed your account history.
What do the courts say?
There’s no single answer at this time. The courts are split. But here are the points at issue in these types of cases:
- The defense must prove parent consent. A Los Angeles judge rejected a renewed arbitration bid by Roblox in a child’s videogame addiction lawsuit, finding that an account linked to his mother’s email failed to prove adult consent. That ruling, in October 2026, leaves intact a prior ruling that Roblox did not sufficiently authenticate an arbitration agreement involving the minor plaintiff.
- The evidence also leads to the opposite. The same LA judge has sent other families to arbitration. In July 2026, he sent claims against Roblox and Microsoft to arbitration, but kept claims against Epic Games in court. His finding was that the evidence was different with respect to whether parents bind a minor plaintiff to arbitration. A month later, he tentatively ruled that four of five lawsuits in coordinated video game addiction litigation belong in arbitration, but found that Roblox failed to show a parent agreed to arbitrate in one case that involved a minor. In other words, the outcome will depend on the specifics of the case.
- A company can lose arbitration if it waits too long. In Uhl v. Roblox, a consumer class-action lawsuit in which a parent sued Roblox with allegations that parents were misled regarding child safety, which resulted in deceptive and unauthorized spending on Robux, and grooming and inappropriate messaging. However, the Ninth Circuit held that Roblox had waived its right to force this proposed class action into arbitration because litigating in federal court took nearly a year—and it sought dismissal on the merits before invoking the arbitration agreement. Because Roblox attempted to first litigate in court, and then sought arbitration, the court did not uphold the agreement. Note, however, that this is less about a child’s capacity to agree than about legal conduct.
- Claims of sexual abuse might be exempt. In November 2025, a California judge rejected a bid by Roblox to arbitrate a child exploitation case, citing the federal Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault and Sexual Harassment Act (EFAA), which prohibits forced arbitration in cases of sexual abuse. At this time, Roblox has appealed the order.
What to do, before harm happens

- Know the account details. Note the email address, birthdate, and payment method tied to any account your child opens. In the Los Angeles case, the deciding issue was whether the mother’s email established her consent.
- Know before you click. Setting up parental controls, linking your credit card, or buying gift cards might be your acceptance of the platform’s terms, yourself. Read the arbitration clause and look for an opt-out window. Some terms allow you to opt out in writing within a set number of days.
- Keep records. Screenshots of account settings, parental control choices, and the dates when your child joined various apps or options can be valuable evidence. Save receipts for in-app purchases. Details like these could become important if a company tries to push you toward arbitration.
- Don’t allow your child to use a false age online. While this can be tempting, particularly since some social media apps don’t allow children under 13, the age restrictions are in place for your child’s safety and protection. The Discord argument in the Heine case relies partly on an adult birthdate entered by an eight-year-old child. An accurate age supports the minor’s protections.
- Talk to a lawyer quickly if harm occurs. Deadlines, preservation of evidence, and how the case is filed can all affect the outcome.
Ultimately, a child’s click doesn’t legally bind the parent on its own. But the line can shift quickly. A court will typically treat a minor’s agreement as voidable by the child, and does not make it the parent’s contract simply because they are the parent. A parent becomes bound when they take action, such as creating the account, entering payment information, setting up parental controls, or accepting updated terms. A parent’s email, alone, does not automatically prove their consent. A parent shouldn’t assume a checkbox decides the matter, either way. That’s why maintaining records and having a lawyer review them if your child is harmed can make the biggest difference in the outcome in your claim.
Read more:
See our guide Choosing a personal injury attorney.