
Washington doesn’t have a dedicated statute spelling out exactly what a prenuptial agreement must contain to hold up in court. Instead, whether an agreement survives a challenge comes down to a two-part test developed through case law.
Couples who sign an agreement assuming it’s automatically binding are sometimes surprised to learn that a judge can still throw it out years later. These agreements can also have consequences beyond traditional divorce issues, including how a personal injury settlement is treated if one spouse is injured during the marriage.
Washington relies on case law, not a model statute
Unlike states that have adopted the Uniform Premarital Agreement Act, Washington has not, which means enforceability is shaped primarily by two Washington Supreme Court decisions:
- In re Marriage of Matson (1986), and
- In re Marriage of Bernard (2009).
Those cases established and reaffirmed a two-prong analysis that Washington courts still apply today.
There is a baseline formality requirement, though. Under RCW 19.36.010, an agreement made in consideration of marriage generally must be in writing and signed by the party against whom it’s being enforced. A verbal understanding between engaged partners, however detailed, ordinarily doesn’t meet that requirement, although limited exceptions may apply.
The two-prong test: fair provisions or a fair process
The first question a Washington court asks is whether the agreement is substantively fair to the spouse who isn’t seeking to enforce it. In other words, whether it makes reasonable provisions for that spouse given the circumstances. If the answer is yes, the analysis generally ends there, and the agreement is enforceable.
If the agreement isn’t substantively fair, it can still be upheld if it was procedurally fair when signed. That requires showing full disclosure of the parties’ property, a meaningful opportunity for independent legal counsel, full knowledge of the agreement’s legal effect, and that both parties entered into it voluntarily.
Courts tend to apply closer scrutiny to the procedural side when an agreement looks patently unreasonable on its face. The more one-sided the terms, the more closely the process behind signing it gets examined.
If an agreement fails both prongs of this test, Washington courts treat it as void, not merely voidable. That distinction is important: a void agreement can’t be salvaged just because both spouses lived by its terms for years afterward. Time and conduct don’t cure the defect on their own.

Fairness is judged at signing, not at divorce
One detail that often trips people up: courts evaluate fairness as of the date the agreement was executed, not as of the date it’s later enforced.
In Bernard, the Washington Supreme Court explained that judging fairness based on when enforcement is sought “would change the test from one of fairness to fortuity.”
To put it another way, an agreement that looked reasonable on the wedding day shouldn’t fail simply because one spouse’s finances changed dramatically over the following decade. Likewise, subsequent changes in financial circumstances don’t necessarily make an initially unfair agreement enforceable.
Timing and pressure matter more than people expect
Washington courts look closely at when an agreement was presented relative to the wedding date, along with whether either party felt rushed or pressured into signing.
In Bernard, a draft agreement wasn’t provided to one spouse until 18 days before the wedding, and a substantially revised version reached her attorney just three days before the ceremony — facts the court considered relevant to whether she had a genuine opportunity for informed, independent review.
There’s no fixed number of days Washington law requires between presenting a prenup and the wedding itself, but presenting one at the last minute invites exactly the kind of scrutiny that can unravel it later.
The same test applies to agreements signed after the wedding
Couples sometimes wait until after marriage to formalize a property agreement, whether because the engagement moved quickly or because a business opportunity or inheritance arose later.
Washington courts apply the same two-prong Matson and Bernard analysis to postnuptial agreements as they do to prenuptial ones, though with an added consideration: spouses owe each other fiduciary duties once married, making full disclosure and voluntary agreement especially important. Even engaged couples have a relationship of trust and confidence that requires good faith and candor.
This matters for couples who initially skipped a prenup and are now considering an agreement to protect a business interest, an inheritance, or assets accumulated separately during the marriage. The legal standard doesn’t relax just because the wedding has already happened, and courts closely examine whether both spouses understood and voluntarily accepted the agreement’s terms.
What a prenup in Washington can’t decide
Because Washington is a community property state under RCW 26.16.030, a prenuptial agreement can reshape how property is characterized and divided — deciding what stays separate property, what becomes shared, and how retirement accounts or a business are treated at divorce.
What it cannot do is control child custody or eliminate child support obligations. Those matters remain subject to the court’s authority and the applicable legal standards, including the child’s best interests, regardless of what the parties agreed to years earlier.
How a prenup can affect a personal injury settlement
A personal injury settlement isn’t necessarily treated as entirely separate or community property in Washington. Under In re Marriage of Brown (1984), compensation for pain and suffering generally belongs to the injured spouse, while damages covering lost wages or medical expenses may be considered community property, depending on the circumstances.
A prenuptial agreement can address how personal injury compensation will be treated if the couple divorces. However, those provisions must still satisfy Washington’s enforceability requirements. Clearly addressing potential injury settlements in advance can help prevent disputes over who is entitled to the money later.
Independent legal counsel isn’t required, but it carries real weight
Washington doesn’t categorically require both parties to hire separate attorneys before signing a prenuptial agreement. Practically speaking, though, independent counsel is one of the clearest ways to establish the procedural fairness prong if the agreement’s terms are ever challenged as substantively unfair. A spouse who signed without any legal advice, especially under time pressure, gives a future court far less to point to when deciding whether the process behind the agreement was fair.
Building an agreement that’s likely to hold up
Couples working through a Washington prenuptial agreement generally strengthen its odds of enforceability by:
- Starting the process well before the wedding date, rather than in the final weeks
- Fully disclosing assets, debts, and income to one another in writing, with that information attached as a schedule to the agreement
- Giving each party a genuine opportunity to review the terms with independent counsel
- Avoiding provisions that leave one spouse with little or nothing, regardless of the length of the marriage
- Keeping child custody and support provisions out of the agreement, since they cannot bind the court on those issues
If you’re considering a prenuptial agreement
Taking a few practical steps early in the process can help ensure your agreement is fair, legally sound, and more likely to withstand a challenge in court.
- Begin discussing terms as early as possible in the engagement, ideally months rather than weeks before the wedding.
- Prepare a full, honest accounting of both parties’ assets and debts before drafting begins.
- Encourage your fiancé or fiancée to review the agreement with their own attorney rather than relying on yours.
- Revisit the agreement if either party’s financial circumstances change significantly during a long engagement.
- Work with an attorney who regularly handles prenuptial agreements in Washington State to make sure the agreement reflects both the substantive fairness and procedural safeguards courts look for.
A prenuptial agreement in Washington isn’t judged by a checklist the way it might be in a state with a specific statute — it’s judged by fairness and process, evaluated years later by a court that wasn’t in the room when it was signed. Building that fairness and process in from the start is the surest way to make sure the agreement means what both spouses thought it meant.