Enjuris Blog | Find Answers and Share Your Accident's Story

Finding answers after your accident

24/7 Free Consult   (800) 734-4134    Log in     EnglishSpanish
  • Find a Lawyer
  • Accident Resources
    • Laws by State
      • Arizona
      • California
      • Colorado
      • Florida
      • Georgia
      • Indiana
      • Montana
      • North Carolina
      • Tennessee
      • Texas
      • View all
    • Personal Injury Law
      • You’ve been hurt. Now what?
      • Do I have a claim?
      • Finding the best attorney to represent you
      • Dealing with Insurance
      • View all
    • Accident Types
      • Car accident
      • Truck Accident
      • Workplace injury
      • Wrongful death
      • View all
    • Workers’ Comp
      • Common work injuries
      • Finding the best workers’ comp lawyers
      • How workers’ comp benefits work
      • Personal injury vs. workers’ compensation
      • View all
    • Injury Guides
      • Spinal Cord/Column
      • Brain Injury
      • Occupational injuries
      • Whiplash
      • View all
    • More
      • Blog
      • Tell Your Story
      • Ask a question
      • Forms and Worksheets
      • For Students
      • About Us
  • Attorney Marketing
    • Become a partner
    • Contribute to our blog
    • Join lawyer directory
    • Partnership Opportunities
Home > Blog > Questions & Answers > What is the Eggshell Skull Rule?

What is the Eggshell Skull Rule?

Contributor: Enjuris Editor How can I contribute?

eggshell skull rule

Jump to section
  • What is the eggshell skull rule?
  • When does the eggshell skull rule apply?
  • Are there any situations when the eggshell skull rule doesn’t apply?
  • The crumbling skull rule

 

The “eggshell skull rule” sounds frightening, but it’s actually a fairly straightforward legal doctrine that helps make certain personal injury plaintiffs recover ALL the damages that stem from their accident.

Let’s take a closer look. 

What is the eggshell skull rule?

The “eggshell skull rule” holds that the defendant’s liability won’t be reduced just because the plaintiff is more susceptible to injury than the average plaintiff. 

The eggshell skull rule protects the rights of a plaintiff whose pre-existing fragility makes them particularly susceptible to injury. Tweet this

The legal doctrine is most easily understood by looking at the 1891 case that established the doctrine:

Andrew Vosburg v. George Putney

In a schoolroom in Waukesha, Wisconsin, 12-year-old George Putney got into an argument with 14-year-old Andrew Vosburg. The 2 were sitting opposite each other across an aisle when George reached across the aisle with his foot and kicked Andrew lightly in the shin.

The kick likely wouldn’t have injured a healthy child, but Andrew was not healthy. Andrew had a tibia infection and the kick aggravated the infection, resulting in a serious injury that prohibited him from ever recovering full use of the limb.

The Supreme Court of Wisconsin held that George was liable for the extensive damages caused by his intentional tort even though George didn’t know about Andrew’s weakened condition.

When does the eggshell skull rule apply?

The eggshell skull rule applies to all negligence and intentional tort cases.

Let’s consider 2 more examples that are more likely to be similar to your situation:

Example #1

Jane is driving east on Cypress Avenue in Redding, California. She’s texting while driving and doesn’t see the station wagon stopped at the stoplight in front of her until it’s too late. Jane slams on her brakes, but she rear-ends the station wagon. 

Though Jane was only traveling 2 miles per hour when she collided with the station wagon, the woman driving the station wagon, Linda, suffers from osteogenesis imperfecta (“brittle bone syndrome”) and suffered multiple fractures as a result of the low-impact collision.

Linda files a personal injury lawsuit against Jane demanding $100,000.

At trial, Jane argues that most people wouldn’t have been injured in the crash and that the brittle bone syndrome is responsible for Linda’s injuries. 

The court holds that, under the eggshell skull rule, Jane is liable for the full $100,000. 

Example #2

John returns home to his apartment complex after being on vacation for a week. It’s the middle of winter and a snowstorm has created a thick sheet of ice on the apartment complex steps. Despite several complaints by others in the apartment complex, the landlord has failed to treat or remove the ice from the steps.

As John is walking up the steps, he slips and falls on his side. John, who has hemophilia, begins to bleed excessively. He is rushed to the hospital and misses 2 weeks of work as a result of the injury.

John sues his landlord for $100,000.

John’s landlord argues that an otherwise healthy person would have suffered minor scrapes from the fall and he should only be responsible for paying the damages associated with minor scrapes.

The court holds that, under the eggshell skull rule, the landlord is responsible for all of John’s medical bills and lost wages. 

Are there any situations when the eggshell skull rule doesn’t apply?

The eggshell skull rule applies to physical injuries in every state. However, only some states allow the plaintiff to apply the eggshell skull rule to mental conditions.

For example, if a plaintiff suffered from PTSD as a result of a car accident, and a subsequent car accident aggravated the PTSD (whereas the subsequent car crash alone wouldn’t have caused PTSD), only some states would allow the plaintiff to recover damages for the aggravation of their PTSD.

The crumbling skull rule

The eggshell skull rule shouldn’t be confused with the crumbling skull rule.

The “crumbling skull rule” holds that, while a defendant is responsible for the damages needed to restore the plaintiff to the position they were in before the accident, the defendant isn’t responsible for putting the plaintiff in a BETTER position.

In other words, the defendant is liable for the injuries caused, even if they are extreme due to the person’s pre-existing condition, but NOT for any debilitating effects of the pre-existing condition that the plaintiff would have experienced anyway. 

Let’s look at an example to clarify these 2 rules:

Susan has brittle bone syndrome. As a result, she suffers several fractures when she slips on some spilled liquid in a grocery store. 

Susan accumulates $200,000 in medical bills to repair the fractures. What’s more, Susan wants to undergo an experimental surgery that would reduce the overall impact of brittle bone syndrome. The surgery would cost $100,000.

Susan sues the restaurant under premises liability laws for $300,000.

Under the eggshell skull rule, the grocery store would be responsible for the $200,000, but not the $100,000 associated with the experimental surgery. To put it another way, the grocery store is not responsible for putting Susan in a better position than the one she was in prior to the accident.

Do you have a pre-condition that might make you particularly susceptible to injury if you’re involved in a car crash or some other accident?

Share your story in the comments below.

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Required fields are marked *. While our editors moderate all comments, Enjuris cannot guarantee the authenticity or accuracy of the information contained in the post. Also, any information you provide in your comment will be made public on our website. Please avoid sharing confidential and personal information.

Legal Rights Defenders - FREE CONSULTATION 24/7

Categories

  • News Stories
  • My Accident Story
  • Resources You'll Love
  • Questions & Answers
Ask a question

In Your State

AZCA CO FL GA IN MT NC TX

Attorney Authors
Enjuris Partners

Denver accident lawyer Mack Babcock

Mack Babcock
The Babcock Law Firm, CO

Texas personal injury and wrongful death lawyer Laura Brown

Laura Brown
Brown Trial Firm

George Lorenzo

George Lorenzo
Lorenzo & Lorenzo, FL

Neal Davis

Neal Davis
Neal Davis Law Firm, TX

Ben Gerber

Ben Gerber
Gerber & Holder Law, GA

Thomas H. Hinson

Thomas H. Hinson
WPMH, GA

Charles Scholle

Charles Scholle
Scholle Law, GA

Tom Murphy

Tom Murphy
Murphy Law Firm, MT

Matt Murphy

Matt Murphy
Murphy Law Firm, MT

Robert E. Wisniewski

Robert E. Wisniewski
Law Offices of Robert E. Wisniewski, AZ

Wilder Pantazis Law Group

Wilder Pantazis Law Group
NC

Contributors

  • Steven G Wigrizer
  • Terry Bryant

Free E-Books

car accident e-book

I've been in a car accident I've been in a truck accident

truck accident e-book

What happens now?

Tags

accident claim accidents arizona Atlanta attorneys bicycle accidents brain injury Car Accidents children Colorado compensation covid-19 damages Denver Florida Georgia guest post Houston insurance company landlord liability law schools lawsuits liability medical malpractice Montana motorcycle accidents negligence personal injury personal injury lawyers pharmaceutical liability premises liability product liability safety settlement slip and falls statute of limitations students Tampa Texas tort toxic tort truck accidents women workers' compensation wrongful death

What is Enjuris®?

A collection of resources to help people at a tough time in their lives. A place to share your story. A national directory of injury lawyers. Supporter of students, families, caregivers and our communities. How can I contribute?


Hire the right lawyer (800) 734-4134

Lawyer Directory
Car accident attorneys
Defective product attorneys
Personal injury attorneys
Medical malpractice attorneys
Wrongful death attorneys
Workers' compensation attorneys

Enjuris Partner Accident & Injury Lawyers

Tampa Personal Injury Attorneys
Lorenzo & Lorenzo (Tampa, Florida)
Finderson Law (Fort Wayne, Indiana)
Wilder Pantazis Law Group (Charlotte, North Carolina)
Williams & Brown (Waco, Texas)
The Babcock Law Firm (Denver, Colorado)
Gerber & Holder Law (Atlanta, Georgia)
Law Offices of Robert E. Wisniewski (Phoenix, Arizona)
Murphy Law Firm (Great Falls, Montana)
WPMH Legal (Macon, Georgia)
Scholle Law (Duluth, Georgia)


Law students

Enjuris' Student Center is a resource for all pre-law college students and current law students. Learn how to get ahead in your studies and the career field, as well be a guest contributor to our blog and apply for one of our scholarships.


Partner with us

If your goal is to help people after an accident or injury – or to prevent them in the first place – we'd love to hear from you! We look to work with educators, healthcare and recovery organizations, insurance providers, law firms and other organizations. Get in touch to see how we can work together. Learn more...


Are you a personal injury lawyer?

Login Add your Firm Lawyer online marketing Free resources for attorneys

Contact us today to get involved.
Services for attorneys
Personal Injury Law Firms Directory
Directory guidelines
Law firm SEO quote
Terms of Use



SEO Advantage®, Inc.    SEOLegal Division, Lawyer Marketing    3690 West Gandy Blvd., Suite 444    Tampa, FL 33611    Contact us today

Enjuris is a platform dedicated to helping people who are dealing with life-altering accidents and injuries. We support students, families, caregivers and communities with resources, personal stories and a national directory of injury lawyers. Read more about Enjuris.


Copyright © 2021 Enjuris.com. All rights reserved. Terms and conditions The accuracy, completeness, adequacy or currency of the content is not warranted or guaranteed. Our site and services are not substitutes for the advices or services of an attorney. We recommend you consult a lawyer or other appropriate professional if you want legal advice. Privacy policy.

SEOLegal.com