Enjuris Blog | Find Answers and Share Your Accident's Story

Finding answers after your accident

24/7 Free Consult   (800) 734-4134    Log in
  • Find a Lawyer
  • Accident Resources
    • Personal Injury Law
      • You’ve been hurt. Now what?
      • Do I have a claim?
      • Finding the best attorney to represent you
      • Dealing with Insurance
      • Laws by State
      • View all
    • Accident Types
      • Car accident
      • Truck Accident
      • Workplace injury
      • Wrongful death
      • View all
    • Workers’ Comp
      • Common work injuries
      • Finding the best workers’ comp lawyers
      • How workers’ comp benefits work
      • Personal injury vs. workers’ compensation
      • View all
    • Injury Guides
      • Spinal Cord/Column
      • Brain Injury
      • Occupational injuries
      • Whiplash
      • View all
    • More
      • Blog
      • Tell Your Story
      • Forms and Worksheets
      • Videos
      • For Students
      • About Us
  • Attorney Marketing
    • Become a partner
    • Contribute to our blog
    • Join lawyer directory
    • Enjuris Excellence badge
Home > Blog > News Stories > Illinois Jury Awards $72 Million in Toxic Tort Case

Illinois Jury Awards $72 Million in Toxic Tort Case

Contributor: Enjuris Editor How can I contribute?

Illinois Jury Awards $72 Million in Toxic Tort Case

Jump to section
  • The Cerro Flow Products lawsuit
  • What is a toxic tort lawsuit?
  • What to do if you’ve been injured by a toxic substance

 

Jurors in Illinois awarded 12 plaintiffs $72 million after finding a copper tubing manufacturer liable for emitting pollutants that caused the plaintiffs to develop cancer and other health issues.

The Cerro Flow Products lawsuit

Cerro Flow Products LLC owns and operates a copper smelting plant in Sauget, Illinois.

In simple terms, copper smelting plants remove impurities from copper concentrate by heating up the copper concentrate at very high temperatures.

In the 2000s, a number of people living in the area surrounding the Cerro Flow smelting plant were diagnosed with cancer. Many of the diagnosed began to suspect that their cancer was caused by the chemical compounds emitted by the plant.

In June 2009, more than 20 plaintiffs filed a lawsuit against Cerro Flow products. The lawsuit alleged that the manufacturer’s smelting plant had emitted dioxins and furans into the air for decades through its furnace and open-pit burning operations, and that these chemical compounds caused their cancers.

The lawsuit further alleged that Cerro Flow knew about the dangerous chemical compounds, but failed to warn residents in the area.

On October 15, 2021, after a 3-week trial in front of Illinois Circuit Judge Chris Kolker, the jury awarded the plaintiffs $24 million in compensatory damages and $48 million in punitive damages.

“The trial required a detailed and scientific explanation as to what dioxins are, how they cause cancer, and why they were a by-product of Cerro’s daily operation for decades,” said plaintiffs’ attorney Lloyd M. Cueto. “Our plaintiffs are wonderful people who have faced tremendous adversity in their battles with cancer. Every one of them had the courage to testify at trial.”

An additional 1,200 cancer-victim plaintiffs in Illinois have filed a subsequent lawsuit against Cerro Flow.

What is a toxic tort lawsuit?

A toxic tort lawsuit alleges that a toxic substance injured the plaintiff or their property.

Toxic tort lawsuits generally arise from 1 of the following situations:

  • Occupational exposure. Workers who are exposed to toxic substances at work may be able to file a toxic tort claim. The most infamous example of occupational exposure is the millions of workers who were exposed to asbestos beginning in the 1930s.
  • Pharmaceutical drugs. A toxic tort claim might arise when a consumer takes a pharmaceutical drug that is unreasonably dangerous or that has unintended side effects.
  • Exposure in the home. When people breathe in or ingest toxic substances in their homes (such as toxic mold), a toxic tort claim might be appropriate.
  • Consumer products. When people use consumer products that cause illness, a toxic tort claim might be appropriate. For example, hand sanitizers that cause permanent damage to the nervous system might result in a toxic tort claim.

It’s relatively rare for a toxic tort lawsuit to arise from a manufacturer releasing toxins into the air or water (although such cases tend to attract media attention when they happen). Nevertheless, these types of cases do happen from time to time, and they often involve copper smelting plants.

For example, in Opportunity, Montana, hundreds of residents joined a lawsuit alleging that the town’s copper smelting plant caused the plaintiffs and even their pets to develop cancer. The lawsuit settled for a confidential amount in 2019.

Similar lawsuits have been filed in Hayden, Arizona, and Tacoma, Washington, where the Asarco Company operates copper smelting plants.

Toxic tort lawsuits are typically based on negligence or strict liability.

In toxic tort cases where negligence is alleged, the plaintiff must establish the traditional elements of negligence:

  • The defendant had a duty to act with reasonable care,
  • The defendant breached their duty, and
  • The breach was the cause of the plaintiff’s injuries.

For example, the plaintiff may argue that a copper manufacturer breached its duty to exercise reasonable care when it released a carcinogen into the air.

In toxic tort cases where strict liability is alleged, there’s no need to prove fault. Rather, the plaintiff need only prove that the activity causing the harm was “abnormally dangerous.”

In determining whether an activity is abnormally dangerous, courts typically consider the following factors:

  • Existence of a high degree of risk of some harm
  • The likelihood that the harm that results will be great
  • Inability to eliminate the risk by exercising reasonable care
  • The extent to which the activity is not common
  • The inappropriateness of the activity to the place where it’s carried on
  • The extent to which the activities value to the community is outweighed by its dangerous attributes

Regardless of the legal theory used, plaintiffs in toxic tort cases must prove causation. In other words, plaintiffs must establish that the toxic substance was the cause of their injury.

Proving causation is typically the most difficult part of a toxic tort lawsuit for 2 reasons.

First, the scientific community doesn’t always agree on whether a toxic substance causes a particular illness.

Second, the symptoms of exposure may not appear until years or even decades after the exposure, allowing the defense to make the argument that some other intervening factor actually caused the harm.

Notably, the federal Clean Air Act requires the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to set emission standards for certain hazardous pollutants emitted by smelters. However, many critics believe that the standards are not strict enough.

Facing facts:Copper smelters in the United States emit more than 50 tons of lead, 30 tons of arsenic, and 20 tons of selenium every single year.

What to do if you’ve been injured by a toxic substance

If you suspect you’ve been injured as a result of exposure to a toxic substance, consider reaching out to an experienced personal injury attorney as soon as possible.

When it comes to toxic tort cases, time is of the essence. If you wait too long to contact an attorney, the statute of limitations may expire on your claim. What’s more, evidence will become increasingly more difficult to obtain and it will become more difficult to establish causation.

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Required fields are marked *. While our editors carefully moderate all comments, Enjuris cannot guarantee the authenticity or accuracy of the information contained in the post. Such information should not be used as a substitute for obtaining legal advice from a professional. We always recommend consulting with an attorney or other legal professional if you require legal advice. Also, know that any information you provide in your comment may be published on our website, so please avoid sharing any confidential, private or personal information that you don’t want to be made public. Lastly, we will not publish any comments that we determine are promotional, hateful or inappropriate.

Legal Rights Defenders - FREE CONSULTATION 24/7

Categories

  • News Stories
  • My Accident Story
  • Resources You'll Love
  • Questions & Answers

In Your State

AZ CA CO FL GA IN MT NC SC TN TX

Attorney Authors
Enjuris Partners

Denver accident lawyer Mack Babcock

Mack Babcock
The Babcock Law Firm, CO

Texas personal injury and wrongful death lawyer Laura Brown

Laura Brown
Brown Trial Firm, TX

Attorney Mark Chappell

Mark Chappell
Chappell, Smith & Arden, SC

Neal Davis

Neal Davis
Neal Davis Law Firm, TX

Atlanta workers’ compensation attorney

Natalie Elkins
Gerber & Holder Law, GA

Roger Finderson

Roger Finderson
Finderson Law, IN

Jack Fine, personal injury attorney

Jack Fine
Fine, Farkash & Parlapiano, FL

Ben Gerber

Ben Gerber
Gerber & Holder Law, GA

Chris Gilreath

Chris Gilreath
Gilreath & Associates, TN

Award-winning Atlanta workers’ compensation attorney

Thomas Holder
Gerber & Holder Law, GA

George Lorenzo

George Lorenzo
Lorenzo & Lorenzo, FL

Matt Murphy

Matt Murphy
Murphy Law Firm, MT

Tom Murphy

Tom Murphy
Murphy Law Firm, MT

Bernard Nomberg

Bernard Nomberg
Nomberg Law Firm, AL

Brett Sachs, California accident attorney

Brett Sachs
Sachs Law, CA

Chelsee Sachs, California accident attorney

Chelsee Sachs
Sachs Law, CA

Charla K. Tadlock, Montana personal injury and workers' compensation attorney

Charla K. Tadlock
Murphy Law Firm, MT

Stephanie Tucker, Denver, CO workers' compensation attorney

Stephanie Tucker
The Babcock Law Firm, CO

Attorney Beau Wilder

Beau Wilder
Wilder Pantazis Law Group, NC

Wilder Pantazis Law Group

Rob Wilder
Wilder Pantazis Law Group, NC

Robert E. Wisniewski

Robert E. Wisniewski
Law Offices of Robert E. Wisniewski, AZ

Contributors

  • Terry Bryant
  • Jason Chalik
  • Daniel Clancy
  • Jacob Emrani
  • John Foy
  • Edward Friedman
  • Bert Louthian
  • Joseph Markey
  • Jim Parrish
  • Isaias Valencia
  • Steven G Wigrizer
  • Doug Zanes

Free E-Books

car accident e-book

I've been in a car accident I've been in a truck accident

truck accident e-book

What happens now?

What is Enjuris®?

A collection of resources to help people at a tough time in their lives. A place to share your story. A national directory of injury lawyers. Supporter of students, families, caregivers and our communities. How can I contribute?


Hire the right lawyer (800) 734-4134

Lawyer Directory
Car accident attorneys
Defective product attorneys
Personal injury attorneys
Medical malpractice attorneys
Wrongful death attorneys
Workers' compensation attorneys

Enjuris Partner Accident & Injury Lawyers

Gainesville, FL Personal Injury Attorneys
Tampa Personal Injury Attorneys
Lorenzo & Lorenzo (Tampa, Florida)
Finderson Law (Fort Wayne, Indiana)
Wilder Pantazis Law Group (Charlotte, North Carolina)
Brown Trial Firm (Waco, Texas)
The Babcock Law Firm (Denver, Colorado)
Gerber & Holder Law (Atlanta, Georgia)
Law Offices of Robert E. Wisniewski (Phoenix, Arizona)
Murphy Law Firm (Great Falls, Montana)


Law students

Enjuris' Student Center is a resource for all pre-law college students and current law students. Learn how to get ahead in your studies and the career field, as well be a guest contributor to our blog and apply for one of our scholarships.


Partner with us

If your goal is to help people after an accident or injury – or to prevent them in the first place – we'd love to hear from you! We look to work with educators, healthcare and recovery organizations, insurance providers, law firms and other organizations. Get in touch to see how we can work together. Learn more...


Are you a personal injury lawyer?

Login Add your Firm Lawyer online marketing Free resources for attorneys Attorney / SEOs newsletter signup

Contact us today to get involved.
Services for attorneys
Personal Injury Law Firms Directory
Directory guidelines
Law firm SEO quote
Terms of Use


Twitter Facebook LinkedIn YouTube Blog Blog feed

SEO Advantage®, Inc.    SEOLegal Division, Lawyer Marketing    3690 West Gandy Blvd., Suite 444    Tampa, FL 33611    Contact us today

Enjuris is a platform dedicated to helping people who are dealing with life-altering accidents and injuries. We support students, families, caregivers and communities with resources, personal stories and a national directory of injury lawyers. Read more about Enjuris.


Copyright © 2022 Enjuris.com. All rights reserved. Terms and conditions The accuracy, completeness, adequacy or currency of the content is not warranted or guaranteed. Our site and services are not substitutes for the advices or services of an attorney. We recommend you consult a lawyer or other appropriate professional if you want legal advice. Privacy policy.

SEOLegal.com

Attention attorneys
and SEO firms
  • Make Enjuris work for your law firm
  • Exclusive offers & discounts
  • Content contribution opportunities