
If you’ve ever been in a position to move a parent or spouse into a nursing home, I don’t have to tell you how stressful the experience can be. It could be rushed, worrisome, and you might even be unsure whether you’re making the right decision for their care. The facility will provide you with a stack of paperwork to sign, either on paper or digitally. And under pressure of taking care of your relative, making arrangements for their move, figuring out the finances, and possibly in the midst of their health crisis, you might sign an arbitration agreement—one that you might not have noticed, and probably don’t fully understand.
But if you sign it, you might give up your family’s right to file a lawsuit against the nursing home, even for abuse or neglect.
As much as you hope never to be in a situation where you’d even have to think about a lawsuit against a nursing home, it’s the unfortunate reality that things happen—and you want to know relevant South Carolina laws before you sign any documents.
What is an arbitration clause?
Arbitration is a private alternative to a public courtroom. When you agree to arbitration, any dispute between parties is decided by a private arbitrator. This person could be selected from a pool familiar to the industry, rather than a jury of ordinary citizens.
A binding arbitration agreement typically means:
- You waive your right to a jury trial;
- The proceeding is kept private, rather than on the public record; and
- The arbitrator’s decision is difficult to appeal.
For a nursing home, this is an attractive prospect. But for the resident and their family, who discover neglect, abuse, bedsores, falls, or a wrongful death, it can limit their options. The family has far less leverage in arbitration than they would in a public lawsuit.
How arbitration works in a nursing home dispute
When a nursing home dispute is governed by an arbitration agreement, the family would file a claim with a private arbitration organization named in the agreement. Each side would present evidence and witnesses before a neutral arbitrator (or sometimes a panel of three arbitrators), rather than a judge and jury.
The arbitrator would hold a hearing and then issue a decision, called an “award.” If the agreement is binding, the award is final and enforceable like a court judgment, with practically no right to appeal, even if the arbitrator got the law or facts wrong.
The proceeding is private, so the facility’s conduct never becomes part of the public record. Discovery (which is the exchange of documents and depositions) is often more limited than in court, which can make it more difficult to find patterns of understaffing or prior complaints. The losing side also frequently shares the costs for arbitration, and these can be significant.
What leads to nursing home dispute arbitration?
This process applies when these two factors are present:
- There’s a valid, signed arbitration agreement in the admission paperwork, and
- The dispute falls within what the agreement covers, which is usually broadly written to capture almost any claim against the facility.
Here are some common examples of situations that could lead to an arbitration:
- Neglect injuries, like bedsores or pressure ulcers, dehydration or malnutrition, or infections from poor care;
- Falls, particularly when a resident is left unassisted and fractures a hip, which can be tied to understaffing;
- Medication errors, such as the wrong drug, wrong dose, or missed medications;
- Abuse, in the realm of physical, emotional or financial mistreatment by the staff;
- Elopement/wandering, such as a resident with dementia who leaves the facility unsupervised and is harmed; or
- Wrongful death, which could happen if neglect or abuse contributes to a resident’s death; the family’s claim can still be funneled into arbitration if the resident or their legal representative signed a valid agreement.
Here’s a useful way to conceptualize this: Arbitration doesn’t change what happened or whether the nursing home was at fault. It changes the forum where the dispute is adjudicated, and it’s often to the facility’s advantage.
But here’s an important caveat—the fact that an arbitration agreement exists doesn’t mean it’s enforceable. If there’s a dispute headed for arbitration, it’s important to investigate who signed the agreement, if they had legal authority, and whether the facility followed the rules. Your South Carolina injury lawyer can review an arbitration agreement before you ever walk into a hearing room… just to make sure.
South Carolina law and nursing home arbitration
South Carolina treats nursing homes as health care institutions. Therefore, injury and wrongful death claims are frequently handled under the state’s medical malpractice framework, which is under South Carolina Code § 15-79-120.
The state requires parties in a South Carolina medical malpractice matter to participate in mediation before trial and, importantly, it expressly allows parties to agree to binding arbitration, non-binding arbitration, early neutral evaluation, or other forms of alternative dispute resolution. Enabling parties to agree to binding arbitration is the legal maneuver that makes the admission-packet clauses enforceable in the first place. In other words, South Carolina law permits a party to contract the dispute out of the courtroom—this is what the facility is asking you to do when you sign the agreement.
The Federal Arbitration Act also strongly favors arbitration agreements, which is why courts often enforce them, even when the person who signed later has regrets.
Protections for families
In most instances, you do not have to sign the arbitration agreement in order for your family member to be admitted to the facility. Many families don’t realize this.
Federal regulations that govern nursing homes that participate in Medicare or Medicaid prohibit facilities from requiring a resident to sign a pre-dispute binding arbitration agreement as a condition of admission (42 C.F.R. § 483.70). The arbitration document is supposed to be voluntary and separate. If an intake employee of the nursing home says you must sign everything in order to move your family member into the facility, this is often simply false. You can decline the arbitration portion while completing the rest of their admission paperwork. Request to see an administrator for clarification.
There some other protections, too:
- Authority to sign is important. Only the resident or a person with legal authority to act on their behalf may sign a document that binds the resident to arbitration. This would include a health care power of attorney or legal guardian. A well-meaning adult child who signs without the authority might not have actually waived anything.
- Some agreements include a rescission window. Many arbitration agreements allow the signer to cancel within a set period (typically 30 days). If you already signed, check the document to see if you’re still within the window.
- Voluntariness and fairness can be challenged. If an agreement was hidden, misrepresented, or presented in a coercive manner, it could be vulnerable to attack as unconscionable.
What to do before you sign a nursing home arbitration agreement
- Slow down: You’re allowed to take the paperwork home and read it thoroughly, or ask for time. A reputable facility will not refuse care over your not signing immediately.
- Ask questions: “Is this arbitration agreement required for admission?” Get the answer, and note who provided the information.
- Look for certain words: Arbitration. Waiver of jury trial. Dispute resolution. These terms matter; if you see a clause with these words, this is what you’re looking at.
- Don’t sign what you don’t understand: If a document gives up a legal right, it’s a reason to pause, not to rush.
- Keep a complete copy: Maintain a record of everything you sign, including the date.
What if you already signed an arbitration agreement?
Don’t assume you have no leverage if an agreement was already signed. There are several factors that could affect whether an arbitration agreement holds up.
These include:
- Who signed
- Whether they had authority
- Whether the facility followed federal rules
- How the document was presented
- What the agreement says
These clauses are challenged successfully more often than families expect, and the only way to know where you stand is to have the paperwork reviewed.
These seem like small details, but they are some of the reasons why representation matters. If your loved one was injured in a South Carolina nursing home, the team at Chappell, Chappell & Newman LLC can help. We’ll review your arbitration agreement, challenge it if the law allows, and work to keep your family’s case where it belongs.