Minnesota Plane Crashes & Aviation Laws

Minnesota Plane Crashes & Aviation Laws

Airplane passengers and their families may be able to recover damages after a plane crash

Plane crash victims and their families may be able to recover damages following a plane crash in the North Star State. Learn about the various legal options, including negligence claims, product liability claims, wrongful death claims, and workers’ compensation claims.
Jump to section


Since the Wright brothers became airborne (briefly) on December 17, 1903, people have been fascinated and terrified by aviation.

Remarkably, flying through the air in what amounts to a giant tube is incredibly safe. Nevertheless, plane crashes do happen.

Let’s take a look at the legal options available to plane crash victims and their families in Minnesota.

What are the chances I’ll be involved in a plane crash?

Aviophobia is the term used to describe the fear of flying. Approximately 40% of the population experiences some fear of flying, and roughly 2.5% of people have a clinical phobia.

Although the number of people who fear flying is quite high, the risks associated with flying are extremely low.

According to Ian Savage, associate chair of the Economics Department at Northwestern University, a person who took a 500-mile flight every day for a year would have a fatality risk of 1 in 85,000.

To look at it another way, large commercial airplanes had 0.27 fatal accidents per million flights across the globe in 2020.

In general, flying is very safe. However, commercial aviation is 50 times safer than general aviation.

  • Commercial aviation refers to scheduled flights that involve the transportation of passengers or cargo. When you purchase a plane ticket from a commercial airline or you purchase a product online and select “UPS Next Day Air Shipping,” the flight operation is considered commercial. Common commercial planes include the Boeing 747, 777, and 737.
  • General aviation refers to all non-scheduled flights. This category includes private aircraft, such as light-sport aircraft, turboprops, and rotorcraft.
Facing factsThe last commercial plane crash in the United States was Continental Flight 3407 on February 12, 2009.

In Minnesota, there have only been 53 total aviation accidents (131 fatalities ) since 1921.

The worst aviation accident in Minnesota history occurred on December 1, 1993 (18 fatalities), when Northwest Airlink Flight 5719 crashed into a group of aspen trees during its final approach to Range Regional Airport in Hibbing, Minnesota. The cause of the crash was pilot error (loss of altitude awareness).

What are the most common causes of plane crashes?

The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) is an independent federal agency charged by Congress with investigating every aviation accident in the United States.

According to the NTSB, the most common causes of commercial aviation accidents include:

  • Pilot error
  • Poor maintenance
  • Air traffic control error
  • Sabotage

The most common causes of general aviation accidents include:

  • In-flight loss of control
  • System component failure
  • Poor weather conditions
  • Mid-air collisions
  • Low-altitude operations
Real Life Example:A single-engine plane crashed near a home in Victoria, Minnesota, killing the pilot.

The NTSB said that some parts from the plane’s tail, including pieces of the left elevator and left horizontal stabilizer fell off the plane during flight.

“Without an elevator and a horizontal stabilizer, the aircraft is not flyable,” NTSB investigator Mike Folkerts said.

The investigation is still pending.

What legal options are available to plane accident victims in Minnesota?

Plane accident victims may have several legal options to recover damages following a plane crash depending on the nature of the accident.

Here are the most common legal options:


Pilots, as common carriers, have a legal duty to exercise the “highest degree of care” when operating a plane. If a pilot fails to exercise the highest degree of care, and an accident results, the pilot can be sued for negligence.

To establish negligence, a plane crash victim must prove the following elements:

  • Duty. The plane crash victim must prove that the defendant owed them a duty of care.
  • Breach. The plane crash victim must prove that the defendant breached the duty of care.
  • Causation. The plane crash victim must prove that their injury wouldn’t have occurred but for the defendant’s breach.
  • Damages. The plane crash victim must prove that they actually suffered some harm.

An example of a situation in which a pilot was found negligent is the Northwest Airlink Flight 5719 crash in Hibbing, Minnesota. In that crash, the pilot simply failed to recognize that he was flying at a low altitude. Notably, the NTSB report following the crash concluded that the pilot had a history of getting angry and performing dangerous maneuvers inflight.

Enjuris tip:In most cases, a plane crash victim can sue the airline (in addition to the pilot) under the legal theory of vicarious liability, which holds an employer liable for the actions of its employees.

Product liability claim

A product liability lawsuit may be appropriate if the plane crash was caused by a defective plane component.

The law recognizes 3 types of defects:

  1. Design defect. A product that is inherently dangerous even when manufactured and used properly is defectively designed.
  2. Manufacturing defect. A product that would have been safe but for some error that occurred during the manufacturing process has a manufacturing defect.
  3. Marketing defect. A product that doesn’t have proper warnings or instructions is an example of a marketing defect.

According to a USA Today investigation, common plane defects include:

  • Faulty fuel tanks that explode and catch fire upon impact
  • Leaking exhaust systems that contribute to engine fires
  • Faulty de-icing systems that fail to keep wings de-iced during flight
  • Pilot seats that slide backward without warning

Federal tort claim

The Federal Aviation Agency (FAA) is responsible for directing and guiding pilots through international airspace. If an FAA employee fails to perform their duties properly, the federal government may be liable for any resulting injuries or deaths.

When suing the federal government, plaintiffs must do so under the Federal Tort Claims Act (FCTA). The FCTA requires plaintiffs to follow special rules and procedures, so we encourage plaintiffs to consult with an attorney in your area who specializes in these complex cases.

Workers’ compensation claim

When most people think about plane crash victims, they think about passengers visiting family members or going on vacation. However, plane crash victims can include airline employees (such as a pilot or a flight attendant).

If an employee of an airline is injured in a plane crash, they may be able to file a workers’ compensation claim.

Enjuris tip:Workers’ compensation is a form of insurance that provides financial benefits to employees who are injured on the job.

Unlike personal injury lawsuits, injured employees who file a workers’ compensation claim don’t need to prove that anyone was at fault for the accident in order to recover damages.

What legal options are available to the families of plane accident victims in Minnesota?

Unfortunately, when a plane falls from the sky, the people on board generally don’t survive.

If a plane accident is caused by someone’s negligent actions or a defective product, certain family members of the deceased passenger may be able to file a wrongful death claim.

As is the case with any personal injury lawsuit, family members who file a wrongful death claim will have to prove fault to receive compensation for their loss.

If the deceased is an airline employee, family members of the deceased may be able to receive compensation by filing a workers’ compensation claim.

The Aviation Disaster Family Assistance Act of 1996

The Aviation Disaster Family Assistance Act was enacted to provide support to families of passengers involved in commercial aviation accidents.

Under the Act, the NTSB must carry out a number of duties that benefit family members following a plane crash. For example, the NTSB must:

  • Provide family members with the name and number of the director of family support services who will be the primary point of contact within the federal government.
  • Designate an independent nonprofit organization to coordinate mental health services for the passengers’ families.
  • Contact families of victims and meet with family members who traveled to the crash location, as well as provide travel assistance and physical care while there.
  • Coordinate with family members to arrange memorial services.
  • Ensure that the airline has a staff to handle calls, provide information, and answer questions from family members.
  • Create a meeting place (usually a hotel or conference center) for crash survivors, family members, and friends to gather and receive updates.

Statute of limitations for aviation accidents in Minnesota

Plane crash victims and their families only have a certain amount of time to file a lawsuit in Minnesota. In most cases, this time limit is 2 years from the date of the crash.

Failing to file a claim within this time period will result in the claim being permanently barred.

There are some exceptions that may limit or extend the 2-year statute of limitations, so it’s a good idea to talk to an attorney as soon as possible following a plane crash to ensure that your legal rights are protected.

Ready to sit down with an attorney to discuss your plane crash claim? Schedule a free initial consultation with an experienced plane crash attorney near you using our free online legal directory.


Free personal injury guides for download to print or save. View all downloads.

Tell your story:
Tell your story - What would you want others to know? Tell us what happened in your accident, and how life has changed for you.

Find an attorney:
Search our directory for personal injury law firms.
See our guide Choosing a personal injury attorney.